Archive for the ‘Flying Advice’ Category

Speed Controllers and Electric Motors: A Few Tips

Sunday, June 28th, 2009

You’ll see a lot of electric helicopters being advertised as having an ESC, or Electronic Speed Controller, as if it was the latest big thing. But it’s the kind of controller that makes these RC helicopters special - not the fact that it has one. All variable speed motors need an ESC, or they won’t work!

The ESC is the throttle control of RC helicopters. It is an electronic device, one side of which connects to the battery and the other side to the motor. A third lead connects to a servo channel on the receiver.

This last lead is often called the servo lead, but that’s a misnomer. What you are doing is using a spare servo channel to do another job - transfer the throttle signal from the receiver to the speed controller, so it can in turn control the speed of the motor.

Most speed controllers on electric helicopters have a BEC (battery eliminating circuit). This allows all the electronic gadgetry on board your chopper - radio receiver, servos etc - to run off just the one central battery pack. They are rated in variable amperages, anything from 5 amps (or less) to 50 plus, depending on the size of the helicopter and what equipment it has on board. It’s important that electric helicopters are equipped with the correct BEC unit for the motor and battery installed.

It is important you choose the correct ESC for the type of motor you have. With brushed motors, speed control is achieved by a simple variation of the amount of power supplied to the motor. It does this by a pulse system. Many pulses a second are delivered; the longer the pulses, the more power is delivered to the motor. ESCs connect to brushed motors with 2 wires.

With brushless motors, the same principle is used. However, to make the motor turn the controller has to select between various sets of windings. Most brushless ESCs are sensor-less speed controllers; they use the residual voltage (Back EMF) in momentarily inactive windings to decide the position of the motor, and then act accordingly.

All brushless ESCs have three wires. Really, all you need to know is that a brushed ESC cannot be connected to a brushless motor, and vice versa.

Collective Pitch Electric Helicopters

Monday, June 22nd, 2009

So far, we’ve spoken about the angle of attack and how it relates to collective pitch (CP) radio control helicopters – but what goes on “under the bonnet”?

The swashplates on collective pitch RC helicopters differ to those on fixed pitch in a number of ways. For a start, the assembly is more complex: linkages from the swash to the rotor blade grips allow for control of the blades via the servos. In addition, when the collective is engaged, the entire swashplate assembly rises upwards, returning to base when the collective is reduced.

Fixed pitch electric helicopters have their blades set for optimum lift on take-off. However, this is of little use in variable winds, or when hovering. And, of course, it makes landing (when the angle of attack should be lowered) more difficult. This is why they have limited appeal outdoors, and why CP is the preferred medium for 3D flight.

It is true that collective pitch RC helicopters are tricky for beginner pilots to learn on. It’s also true that as far as changing direction (cyclic pitch) is concerned, they work the same as fixed pitch choppers.

However, CP electric helicopters have many advantages over FP. For a start, they have the advantage of totally controllable pitch; meaning sensitivity can be adjusted both for the prevailing weather conditions and for the ability of the pilot.

As well as using the transmitter to adjust the pitch angle of the blades on a minute-to-minute basis, the sensitivity can be dampened or increased via the transmitter settings (this is also true of the cyclic, of course). It is also possible to set the blade pitch manually to allow for varying weather and flying conditions – something that just isn’t possible on a fixed pitch craft.

All in all, if you are looking for a chopper that’s “for keeps”, then collective pitch electric helicopters with digital Tx, are your best bet to choose from. Invest in a training rig and/or simulator program, and the sky is yours.

Collective Pitch – What it Means in Detail

Sunday, June 21st, 2009

RC helicopters fly by means of rotor movement – that is obvious. However, the closer that rotor movement is to real helicopter flight, the better RC electric helicopters will fly.

For this reason, many pilots – even beginners – opt for collective pitch RC helicopters - starting as they mean to go on.

To understand how collective pitch RC helicopters work, you have to understand what the term “pitch angle” means. This is the angle of the rotor blades relative to the air flowing over them. When the blades are moving, it is better known as the “angle of attack”. To keep the helicopter level and straight – or to perform manoeuvres - the pilot must vary the angle of attack depending on the air flow hitting the advancing blades.

When fixed pitch electric helicopters lift off, they have to do so by throttle speed alone. Although the swash plate allows for cyclic changes - i.e. tilting of the entire rotor disc, the individual blades are immovable. With collective pitch helicopters, the blades can be adjusted to provide the best angle of attack to the oncoming air flow. In addition, the swashplate lifts and lowers, thus increasing or decreasing the lift of the helicopter. Both fixed pitch and collective pitch electric helicopters have cyclic control in which the entire rotor disc is tilted to change the angle of attack. However, this tilting also changes the RC helicopter’s direction of travel - it is of little use when the aircraft is taking off, descending, hovering or performing small and intricate movements.

Therefore, any helicopter equipped with collective pitch has the manoeuvrability and adaptability of a full sized craft. All RC helicopters flown competitively are collective pitch.

Balancing the flybar

Tuesday, June 2nd, 2009

An unbalanced flybar will upset the entire stability and control of your aircraft. You will soon know if it’s unbalanced if you remove the main blades and run the engine - an unbalanced flybar will cause the helicopter to vibrate.

All Electric Helicopters are equipped with balance weights, the main function of which is to increase gyroscopic stability. It follows that they should be adjusted to give the least vibration.

This usually means setting the weights at different distances from the paddles, since the main cause of unbalanced flybars are variations in their weight. The problem is that the weights supplied with remote control helicopters are usually too light to make a difference. Other methods need to be used.

One of which is to move the paddle itself.

First, check the paddles are not at their furthest point of travel (adjust them if need be) and that the weights are parked next to the paddles. Ensure the pitch is set at zero (see separate article for how to do this)

Now, loosen one of the paddles via its retaining screw. Slide the paddle and weight outwards on the shaft just a tad, retighten and check again.

If the vibration has lessened, keep doing this with that paddle until the vibration has gone. If it is worse, move the paddle back to its original position, tighten, and then start again on the other side. You may need to adjust both sides anyway, as the paddles should be as matched as possible for best results. ‘Fine tuning’ can now be done with the weights, as before.

If the problem isn’t resolved, then check the flybar and swash for signs of warping. If this is the case, they will need replacing.

Rotor Head adjustments – the fly bar ratio

Friday, May 22nd, 2009

Although they will often see it mentioned in their manual, most people don’t understand what the fly bar ratio is, let alone how to measure it. This is a shame, as the manufacturer will have gone to great lengths to set up the best ratio for each of their RC Helicopters – all to no avail.

Many things about the fly bar will affect the way your helicopter performs. The length of the bar, size of the paddles, weight of the bar, and its alignment to the main blades will all affect how responsive and accurate it is to cyclic control. This last alignment is called the fly bar ratio.

The ratio measures the number of degrees the rotor blades move, per degree of fly bar tilt. For example, a ratio of 1:1 means that for every degree the fly bar tilts, the rotor blade will pitch by one degree as well. This is quite a high figure – most Electric Helicopters will have a smaller ratio than this. The lower the ratio, the less distance the main blades will move per degree of fly bar tilt.

All RC Helicopters have at least two fly bar ratio settings, which are adjusted depending on the work you want the helicopter to do. Look at the linkages, and you may see the location points.

It is very easy to work out the ratio, so long as you have a pitch gauge, protractor and spirit level. The April 2008 edition of RC Heli Mag (www.rchelimag.com) has a detailed explanation of how to do this, but briefly it’s as follows:

The fly bar is first tilted to its furthest movement, and the angle of tilt for the fly bar and main blades are measured with the protractor and pitch gauge. This is repeated on the other side.

The total degrees of travel is worked out for the fly bar and blades (for example, a measurement of -4 and +3 would give a total difference of 7 degrees).

The main blade figure is divided by that of the fly bar, to give the ratio.

This ratio is often overlooked, or crudely guessed at. However, it is crucial to the performance of all RC Helicopters, and well worth checking from time to time.

Rotor head components – the fly bar and washout mechanism

Thursday, May 21st, 2009

The design and mechanics of RC Helicopters are based on those of their full-size cousins. Most Electric Helicopters have a fly bar, meaning they are either Hiller or Bell-Hiller construction. The fly bar works to both stabilize and control the helicopter.

The fly bar connects to the swash plate via a fly bar control linkage. In collective pitch Electric Helicopters, this linkage connects to a washout assembly, sited between the swash plate and the fly bar itself.

What does the washout ‘wash out’, exactly? The answer is, any unwanted collective input to the fly bar.

The swash plate inputs both collective and cyclic controls to the rotor blades. In Hiller RC Helicopters, the cyclic is input via the fly bar, whilst in Bell-Hiller models some of the cyclic is input direct from swash to rotor. In both cases, however, the fly bar is ‘immune’ from collective input; it responds to cyclic only. This is the reason for the washout assembly. All CP Electric Helicopters have some form of washout – naturally, FP helis don’t need it.

When the swash plate moves cyclically and/or collectively, the movement inputs to the washout. This then ‘mixes out’ the collective input before passing the resultant ‘clean’ cyclic info to the fly bar via the control arm.

The rotor blades still receive their collective input from the swash. The way the washout works, is by sliding down the main mast as the swash plate is raised – cyclic tilting is unimpeded.

If all this sounds confusing - don’t worry! Your main job is to keep regular checks on the assembly and linkages to make sure they don’t loosen or become too stiff. The helicopter will take care of the rest.

Linkage adjustments on the rotor head

Monday, May 18th, 2009

No two Electric Helicopters are the same, but linkages don’t vary much. Neither does the way they are set up.

Since the Bell-Hiller mixing head is fast becoming the ‘weapon of choice’ for all serious fliers, it is what we are using in all articles relating to the rotor head. Hence, some components – such as the BH mixer arm – won’t be present on beginner’s RC Electric Helicopters. However, the same prime linkages are present on even the simplest of 3 channel models.

Electric Helicopters should always be set up for maximum response and control, with minimum wear-and-tear. Linkages are an important factor in this.

For example, servo horns have several settings, allowing the pilot to vary the deflection of the servo linkages. For example, the horn linkages can be adjusted if there is any collective (lifting) movement of the swash plate during cyclic operations. If there is, then the ball-links can be moved outwards on the servo horn to compensate (or different length linkages employed if you’ve reached the outermost hole).

However, it must be remembered that rotor head components are often designed to fit several RC Helicopters, so not all the settings may be appropriate for your model. Incorrectly set servo adjustment can cause the servo to bind, and eventually wear out – just as car brakes do. You will know if the servos are binding, as they emit a buzzing noise when cyclic is applied.

Another essential factor is the ball links. All Electric Helicopters have these, and they must be free to move, without being too loose. Check how the ball-links feel: if they are too tight or too loose, squeeze gently with your ball-link pliers to adjust them. It’s important all adjustments are equally set.

The fly bar control arm linkage is present in all RC Electric Helicopters. Because it is responsible for changing the pitch of the fly bar paddles (and thus, the pitch of the rotor disc) it is essential it is regularly checked for tightness and alignment. As a rule, the bell-crank leverages should be at right angles to the deck. A small amount of play is allowed, however.

Ditto the linkages to the rotor blade grips – check for tightness and stability.

Never over tighten plastic components or you will strip the threads. It is best to upgrade any plastic to metal, wherever possible.

These are only a few of the linkages employed in RC Helicopters, but they are the ones most likely to need regular checks.

Adjusting the linkages on RC Electric Helicopters

Saturday, May 16th, 2009

If you are intending to build RC Electric Helicopters from ‘scratch’, i.e. from a kit or plan – you will need to know how to adjust linkages.

If you’ve decided to upgrade to a new rotor head, tail or blades – you will need to know how to adjust linkages.

From impromptu crashes, to badly shipped, ‘ready-to-fly’ RC Helicopters that aren’t – there are a hundred reasons why you will need to know about linkage adjustments.

Whenever you read about RC Helicopters, the linkages will inevitably come into it. To get Electric Helicopters to fly well the blades must be balanced, the tail rotor level, the centre of gravity aligned accurately, and so on. All rely on linkage adjustments.

Tightening the last screw on a kit build is only the start of it. Electric Helicopters are a complicated labyrinth of bell-cranks, push-rods and interconnecting arms – and we haven’t left the swash plate yet! Your bird may look completed, but rest assured you have several more hours of work ahead of you - loosening, realigning, measuring and adjusting – before you can safely think about flying her.

Any toolbox that services the linkages on RC Helicopters needs a few specialised items. Aside from watchmaker’s screwdrivers, ball-link pliers and so on, you will need: electrical tape, protractors, spirit levels (large and small) engineering rulers, a tape measure and some watch-maker’s forceps.

The protractor is the most important tool, and you can pick one up for a few pence from any dime store. If you can’t remember what it does – revise your school maths! In RC Electric Helicopters, angles are important.

Rotor head developments – the Bell-Hiller mixing head

Friday, May 15th, 2009

This is most often seen as an upgrade to a normal fly bar head, although some of the more expensive Electric Helicopters do fit it as standard.

As the name suggests, the B-H takes the best features from both types of rotor head: the stability of the Hiller (fly bar) mechanism, coupled with the responsiveness of the Bell (fly bar less).

As a result, you still have the stabilizing effect of the fly bar. However, instead of fly bar linkages passing on the swash plate data to the main blades, the swash plate links to the blades directly via an interface called the mixing arm. The gyroscopic data from the fly bar also inputs to the mixing arm. This allows for instant response to the cyclic input data, together with gyroscopic stability, at reasonably low cost.

As RC electric Helicopters shrink in size, they get more sensitive anyway, so for most people a standard Hiller head works just fine on smaller choppers. However, once you reach 350 size and beyond you may want to think about upgrading to a Bell-Hiller combo.

The mixing arm is located below the main rotors. Both the swash plate and the fly bar input directly into this. The combined output is then relayed to the blade grips. This means instant cyclic input from the swash plate, mixed with stability and control input from the fly bar.

As the fly bar tilts, the mixing arm is raised or lowered. This has the effect of altering the pitch of the main blades accordingly. The pilot can make fine adjustments to the fly bar input of the mixing arm, varying the influence the fly bar has over cyclic control i.e. the pitch of the main blades. The Bell, or swash plate component is pre-set at the factory and normally cannot be adjusted.

Latest Developments: Electronically Stabilized, Fly Bar Less Electric Helicopters

Thursday, May 14th, 2009

On conventional RC Helicopters, the fly bar acts to both amplify the swash plate movements, and keep the helicopter balanced during flight. To effect a cyclic change in the rotor disc, the fly bar transmits these cyclic changes to the main blades via linkages or rods.

In a fly bar less (Bell) rotor head, the swash plate inputs directly to the main blades. Higher torque servos replace the amplification effect of the bar. This allows for an instant, sensitive response – some people would say, a bit too sensitive.

But the fly bar has a very important primary function – that of gyroscopic balance. Without this dampening effect, Electric Helicopters would flip about all over the place during high speed manoeuvres. So, how does a fly bar less rotor head correct this?

Well, when they first came out it was by adding extra weight and blade adjustment. But the latest development is Electronic Stabilization, otherwise known as an Electronic or Virtual Fly bar.

ES heads have a series of electronic gyros, and an electronic mixer unit, in place of the fly bar.

The pilot transmits a signal in the usual way. This is then passed from the receiver to the mixing unit, which takes the pilot’s commands and the information from the gyros, mixes them and sends the resultant data to the swash plate and servos as a CCPM input.

The sophisticated software also adds other little ‘touches’ to make the heli fly as much like a fly bar model as possible. Lag is minimum, and response and stability superb.

Fly bar less RC Helicopters used to be restricted to 1000mm giants. However, Electronic Stabilization heads can be fitted to the most micro of RC helicopters, albeit at a price. Hopefully, cost will come down as they become more popular.